PDA

View Full Version : (Apr 14, 2009): "When Words Can Kill: 'That's So Gay' - Anti-Gay Taunts in School Lead to 11-Year-Old's Suicide and Rising Calls for Change" (ABC)


CGP
04-14-2009, 08:51 PM
Full Report @ ABC (http://abcnews.go.com/Health/MindMoodNews/Story?id=7328091&page=1)


Carl Joseph Walker-Hoover was 11-- hardly old enough to know his sexuality and yet distraught enough to hang himself last week after school bullies repeatedly called him "gay."

Massachusetts mother finds her 11-year-old son hanging by an extension cord.The Springfield, Mass., football player and Boy Scout was ruthlessly teased, despite his mother's pleas to the New Leadership Charter School to address the problem.

Sirdeaner L. Walker, 43, found Carl hanging by an extension cord on the second floor of the family's home April 6, just minutes before she was going to a meeting to confront school authorities again.

"I am brokenhearted," she told ABCNews.com. "We worry about the economy and about Iraq, but we need to be worried about our schools."

Walker, who works as a director of homeless programs, said Carl -- a slight child who loved his schoolwork -- had endured endless taunts since he started sixth grade in September.

The boy had been active in his church, taking communion on the recent Palm Sunday and playing a wise man in the Christmas play. He helped the needy and a black history program.

"That's the type of kid he was," Walker said. "You could rely and count on him."

Walker said her son's 11-year-old tormentors were worse than the breast cancer she had survived four years ago.

In an ironic twist, the boy would have turned 12 on April 17 -- the same day students in thousands of schools across the country will participate in the annual Day of Silence to bring attention to anti-gay harassment in schools.

"There was no reason for the mother to believe he was gay," said Gay, Lesbian and Straight Education Network spokesman Daryl Presgraves. "It just happens he was someone his peers targeted, calling him, 'girlie,' 'gay' and 'fag.' According to the mother, it was a daily occurrence."


Just last week Bill and Janis Mohat filed suit against Ohio's Mentor High School, alleging their son, who, like Carl, did not identify himself as gay, shot himself after being tortured with homophobic slurs.


In a 2005 survey -- "From Teasing to Torment: School Climate in America" -- students said their peers were most often bullied because of their appearance, but the next top reason was because of actual or perceived sexual orientation and gender expression.

In that report, by the GLSEN and Harris Interactive, students said teachers rarely interfered in cases of gay-related bullying, either because they are embarrassed or don't know what to do.

"The truly unfortunate thing is because of the societal atmosphere surrounding gay and lesbian life in the U.S., administrators are reluctant to act or fail to act," said Eliza Byard, GLSEN's executive director, who attended Carl's memorial service.

"The key is absolute, direct, even-handed, no-nonsense approach to all aspects of bullying," she told ABCNews.com."At this cultural moment, homophobic language is the ultimate weapon. We have to address the use of that language like any other forms of name-calling and harassment."

The National Youth Violence Prevention Resource Center estimated that nearly 30 percent of American youth are either a bully or a target of bullying.

In addition, researchers at the Yale School of Medicine, in a new review of studies from 13 countries, found signs of an apparent connection between bullying, being bullied and suicide.

GLSEN's own research indicates that LGB youth may be more likely to think about and attempt suicide than heterosexual teens.

According to a 2001 study published in the American Journal of Public Health, "The majority of the evidence is in favor of common causes for suicide that affect all youth, but which LGB youth are more likely than their heterosexual peers to experience."

Suicide rates among children Carl's age are very low, according to Ann Haas, director of the Suicide Prevention Project at the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, but they are anecdotally "creeping up."

"It's absolutely tragic," Haas said of Carl's suicide. "The really disturbing thing is the degree to which 'gay,' 'lesbian' and all pejorative terms are a cover for the bullying itself. The meaning of it is unclear."

CGP
04-14-2009, 08:53 PM
What this young boy endured (& could no longer deal with) is experienced by many young people across America & beyond. It's appalling and is the direct consequence of living in a society which says from the outset that gay people are "less than" everyone else. Unless you are gay and have experienced the kind of oppression this young boy endured, you can not know how horrendous it is.

Laura Cereta
04-14-2009, 09:54 PM
This is so sad and heartbreaking... 11 years old... *shaking head*

Horizon
04-15-2009, 12:13 AM
And I have had people chew my ass for allowing my daughter to leave school in her Jr. year, and obtain her GED.:thinking:

Jester
04-15-2009, 12:20 AM
We must be moving in reverse since I was that age. It was pretty open. Must be this new generation.

Jester
04-15-2009, 12:21 AM
And I have had people chew my ass for allowing my daughter to leave school in her Jr. year, and obtain her GED.:thinking:

Aren't you in Southern California?

Horizon
04-15-2009, 02:08 AM
Aren't you in Southern California?

NO, I live in a SMALL town in So. OREGON. Very conservative, though not as bad as it used to be. The farther north you go, the more liberal Oregon gets. While she did not experience the taunting this boy did, it was subtle enough to make her very uncomfortable. She is very physically, obviously gay. It was not as bad as it could have been, but it was enough that she just didnt want to deal with it. She is much happier away from it all.

Jobu86
04-15-2009, 02:27 AM
The word "gay" was thrown around a lot as an insult in my junior high and high school, but actual gays were treated with total respect and were pretty popular. Our homecoming king was very openly gay. Pretty strange.

CGP
04-15-2009, 02:42 AM
The word "gay" was thrown around a lot as an insult in my junior high and high school, but actual gays were treated with total respect and were pretty popular. Our homecoming king was very openly gay. Pretty strange.

It's sad that the "gay" slur has become the quickest way for one young person to insult another young person. What kind of message does that promote about people who are gay? A very bad one. The associations are all negative. It's a tough life being gay, especially for young people who have already become aware of their orientation & who know, in so many ways, that the world around them is hostile to their existence.

TheTaoOfBill
04-15-2009, 12:42 PM
At my high school even the gay students were calling each other fags. No one was offended by the term gay. It was just another word with multiple definitions.

I mean yeah they'd get pissed if you actually said it straight to them as an insult on their sexuality but if your tone of voice was playful, which it almost always is, no one cared.

I still don't get the hubbub. I say that's so gay all the time. My gay friends tell me I'm gay when I do something childish or stupid. It's just a word. It shouldn't be taken so seriously

If people want to attack someone for being gay they will find ways to do it no matter what words become off limits.

My friends (including my gay ones) understand there is a difference between saying "That's so gay" and actually attacking someone's sexuality.

And generally the people that do get so worked up over the word I try to avoid anyway because I'm not big on being PC so they probably wouldn't like a lot of things I say.

I'm not interested in pleasing the PC crowd.

Jester
04-15-2009, 04:20 PM
I still don't get the hubbub. I say that's so gay all the time. My gay friends tell me I'm gay when I do something childish or stupid. It's just a word. It shouldn't be taken so seriously


I won't pretend I don't use the word gay/fag, but I admit I usually make an effort to not use the term in a derogatory fashion. Humor is touch and go on the word. I doubt this 11yo found it humorous. More likely, he felt isolated and his hormones kicking in probably amplified that perception.

There was only one suicide my entire public school voyage. It was a guy that got caught masturbating, last name Wang. Guess what insult probably added the most fuel to the fire. I knew his brother, but not the person himself.

Jester
04-15-2009, 04:24 PM
A parallel would be the "don't jew me out of my money" reference. It is definitely offensive, even if it is in humor. If you have a very close Jewish friend and they actually say it in fun, that is a different story.

TheTaoOfBill
04-15-2009, 04:47 PM
I just don't think I'm going to drive anyone to suicide by saying "you're so gay" in a playful manner.

There is a difference between being offensive and being cruel. The kids harassing Carl were cruel. And even if it wasn't the word gay they were using they probably would have used another word to torment him.

Bullying has existed far longer than the word gay.

I know one of the very first things I'm going to teach my kids is how to stand up for themselves and others.

You are never going to get rid of bullying. Bullying will always exist. What you can do is teach your kids to handle a bully.

Teach them how to throw a few punches if you have to.

My parents flat out told me to not be afraid to fight. They told me if I got into a fight that was the result of someone harassing me or throwing the first punch I could consider my suspension a school vacation and get out punishment free.

I think that's the biggest problem. A lot of kids are taught to ignore bullies. Ignore them and they will go away when in reality that is exactly the opposite of the truth. I've seen so many kids try this strategy and it only makes it worse. The bullies will try even harder and do things even more harsh in order to force a response out of you.

The real anti bully mechanism is letting a bully know you're not afraid to punch them in the nose if they cross the line.

Jester
04-15-2009, 05:42 PM
I recommend allowing your kids to take some elementary wrestling classes. Whether it be a team thing or just a quick grasp of the fundamentals. I don't really like wrestling as a full time sport for kids though because I knew far too many friends that were f*ed up for life from just one bad match. I had a friend that was a tiny little guy that showed me some of the fundamentals very early on.

Making a bully submit is far more damaging than a punch. I try not to throw punches when I fight because you really have to cause some damage before most will submit.

Once you have some confidence, you can end most bullying with a simple serious look asking "are you sure you are ready to do this?" The answer is almost always no. The ones that say yes are either stupid or have a decent chance of being the victor, so be prepared to say yes yourself.